One compromise solution would be to have the book have two parts. Part I - containing just the bare necessities to navigate the trail, find lodging, food, water etc. And part II containing historical data about sites and all the other bonus stuff that makes the guide 1.5lbs instead of only 3 oz. Those who don't really want to read about the stuff don't need to bring it and can rip out of the book the relevent pages and put them in a ziplock.
Me personally, I am likely to read that type of stuff before going on the trip. But only carry the very bare information.